Over on Faith and Theology (and down under in Australia), Ben Myers has drawn up Twelve Theses on Libraries and Librarians. Ben is a theologian rather than a librarian, though evidently wise in any case, and might well qualify as the next patron saint of libraries. Do check out his entire list.
Most of the points are spot on, though number 7 needs some revision:
"7. The library is... the safest and friendliest place on earth. More than that: the library is the institutionalisation of intellectual friendship. Which of us, admiring a shelf laden with the thoughts of dead authors, has never felt that these books love one another, even as they love to dispute and declaim? When I was a boy, I played hide-and-seek with my brothers among the stacks, while my mother slaved over her PhD. If history is a tangle of weeds and briers, the library is that commodious garden in which children play and every flower blooms."
I think yes and no. While libraries are known for a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere, and staff (hopefully) go out of their way to be friendly to patrons, it would be misleading to characterize libraries as necessarily "safe". As we often tell parents who think it perfectly reasonable to leave their kids in the Children's Room, a public place is a public place. One shouldn't leave children unguarded anymore than pocket books unattended. (To be fair, Ben has academic libraries more in view than public libraries, but I don't think "safe" is the best descriptor in either case.)
I especially like the way points 2, 4, and 5 blend into a wonderfully ambiguous portrait of librarianship -- radical and conservative at the same time:
"2. [Librarians] are in truth the most progressive and visionary figures... like bloodhounds, always hot on the trail of the future. Their demure appearance is a cunning disguise which allows them to perpetrate their radicalism all the more effectively. It is a camouflage net thrown over an armoured vehicle.
"5. In all the world there is nothing more dangerous than a library. Within any library are the seeds for the overthrow of the world. What bloody revolution cannot be traced back finally to a library? Or to some book that lay waiting through silent centuries for the day when it would be unsheathed? The rule of silence – upheld in all libraries since time immemorial – is a ruse. It is the silence of a tiger crouching in the reeds."
And yet:
"4. There is nobody more conservative than a librarian. Their enthusiasm for constant change and reinvention springs from an even deeper commitment to what has been received from the hand of the past. The library is an angel whose wings are spread out in fierce and loving protection of the past, while its face stares deep into the eerie light of the future."
I'll mention one more point concerning the autonomy of head librarians:
"10. Every head librarian is (or ought to be) vested with virtually unlimited executive powers. The library is one of those institutions in which benevolent dictatorship is not only desirable but essential. The head librarian is the captain of a ship at sea: her word alone is law. The importance of these executive powers lies in the fact that the librarian is answerable only to the collection, just as the pope is answerable only to God and a ship’s captain only to the devil."
A rather creative way of framing the issue of accountability (and timely for us in Nashua: Ben even gets the gender right, as it so happens, for our
new director, Jen Hinderer, who started three weeks ago). It would be interesting to come up with a list of institutions/careers where "benevolent dictatorship" is highly esteemed.
Thanks to Ben Myers for these wonderful theses.